After High School Placement: What Are Your Options?

Guest blog by Maurice Frumkin, Founder of NYC Admissions Solutions

It seems like I’m getting more and more frantic calls from new clients with rising 9th graders this time of year – after high school placements have been made.   Many of these families think all hope is lost. 

A common scenario involves families who went through the NYC high school application process but are not happy with the results. 

Whether the student ended up being matched to a lower ranked choice school, didn’t get an offer from a specialized high school, or didn’t get an offer from an independent (private) school of choice, there are thousands of students in these situations each year.  Many of these students continue on to their assigned school, resigned to stay there for the duration. 

It’s important to have a handle on the potential options you may not learn about until it’s too late.  These may include:

a.      Applying to other schools for 10th grade.  Yes, there are fewer seats, but there are also fewer applicants.  In fact, the probability of securing an offer at that coveted, dream school may be higher than it was in 8th grade.    But don’t miss the opportunity to complete the application(s) and meet with your 9th grade counselor in the fall.  And if you fell just short on that audition last fall, consider some additional preparation sooner rather than later.

b.      Taking the SHSAT again in the fall of 9th grade, especially if your score was respectable in 8th grade.  Yes, you can take it twice.  It may be worth considering some additional preparation so that you’re not left out in the dust once again come fall.  There are many students in this situation every year who do not take advantage of this opportunity.

c.       Staying put.  Many 9th grade students apply to other schools for 10th grade; generally speaking, you have nothing to lose.  Get a less-than-acceptable result later, stay where you are.  And many do.  Sometimes the known entity is the best option, so give it a try and try to avoid pre-conceived notions!  After all, going to high school is a major transition, so give yourself a break.

d.      If you are desperate:  Considering other types of schools that may still have seats this time of year and into the fall, including parochial, charter, and yes, even some independent.  Understand your dream school may be filled and cast the widest net possible.

Bottom line:  Keep an open mind, and don’t give up – even if that means staying where you are.    Be honest with yourself and consider whether your school search strategy was sound the first time around, and consult with an expert.  You may be pleasantly surprised.

Maurice Frumkin  is former Deputy Executive Director of High School Enrollment with the NYC Department of Education, and a former admissions officer in NYC independent schools. Maurice has conducted dozens of workshops on NYC high school admissions in all 5 boroughs in front of thousands of families - including workshops on admission to the elite specialized high schools - and he has personally counseled hundreds of families on effectively navigating this complex process.